Friday, June 20, 2008

Anorexia and Hi Glam dolls - revisiting a thought

Sometimes you can’t win for trying. While I am often passionate about my views, I am honest enough to admit my ignorance on some subjects. But having a view that is not popular on a topical issue can often lead to unique response from the internet.

Let’s look at my comments on the anorexic looking Hi-Glam dolls.

“But these Hi-Glam dolls are different. Yes they have various races covered. No they don’t represent women as anything more important than objects to be looked at because of how they dress. Yes it’s good they are dressed more substantially than a music video hoochie. But they are all anorexic. Seriously, they are proportioned like twigs.”


Now I do know a few throughout the internet agreed with my assessment. But when you are in a pool so big, sometimes you run into those that have a different view. And since I keep an eye out for where my posts are mentioned I do notice.

Thus I ran into these responses from girls (or women I have no idea) that love the dolls and dislike my thoughts.


Now the poor spelling aside I find this interesting. My concern is the effect that these dolls are having on the young girls they are marketed to. It’s the same concern that has enveloped the high fashion modeling industry. It’s why Italy, England and Spain have all placed bans or made comments on the weight of models in their country.

But the above comments seem unable to understand my comments. Which I thought were obvious. Yet one wants to resort to violence over speaking honestly about the dolls, and another seems almost envious of their death-like looks.

Now I will bypass the fact that anime is a well respected art form loved by tens of millions. But the comment “article was gay” says a lot about the writer. I may be too old to know the latest slang that is out, but what is that supposed to mean? Obviously it’s an insult, but I generally enjoy a bit more in my insults. Perhaps a bit of depth and points of correction or disagreement.

But I digress.

Barbie is far from perfect, but her proportions were changed because she was so unrealistic. To be unable to accept the shape of a Barbie doll today as positive versus the Hi-Glam is to say that Marylyn Monroe was less sexy and attractive than Mary Kate Olsen or Jack Skellington.

Since it seems some did not understand my point before I will be blunt, direct and simple. I’ve lived across a good part of the globe, seen women of every race and ethnicity. I know guys in every country I’ve lived in, and between the thousands of people I have known in my life, not one has ever found an anorexic woman attractive. There is simply nothing to like or admire about someone that is scarcely more than a skeleton. It’s not appealing to anyone, it’s ugly in the most sick manner.

So I don’t know anything about dolls. But I do understand that anything that suggests a girl or woman should weigh as much as a softball and look like a corpse is unhealthy and wrong. It’s America and others don’t have to agree, but I will make my thoughts known.

If only one girl or woman decides to eat a hamburger and let it stay in her stomach then I’m pleased I wrote these posts. And if anyone disagrees they can go to hell.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I found this article while searching for criteria on the aforementioned dolls. Wow. Anorexic dolls? I think not.

I first discovered the Hi Glamm girls on a routine trip to Kmart when I was going to purchase a hot plate. Out of habit I crossed the store to examine the doll clothes. I am a collector and lover of a Japanese doll called Blythe, whose clothes are not marketed in the U.S., so I was looking for other doll clothes that would fit my darling doll. This was when I saw them: peaky, lanky, and altogether creepy--but somehow intriguing. I sifted through them to find one with black hair, and my search proved quickly fruitful. What I found was what I could only suppose to be Asian, a health and-fitness themed doll with her bangs cut in a widow's peak. Really? I thought. Stock hair, in a widow's peak. And so strange, too...unique, that was the word. I glanced at the bottom of the box and recognized the name of an Italian toy designer (memory fails to surrender the name). The look of these dolls reminded me of an Italian anime style cartoon called Winx. And the doll is only $7? I was sold.


I brought her home and immediately cut her bangs straight (don't worry, I have had practice in customizing dolls, I did not butcher her), and sewed her a very long pair of jeans to replace that terrible short skirt. She is my favorite new doll. I think, if you were to cut her arms and legs shorter, you would find the doll slightly less anorexic looking, though I would discourage you towards it, as it would ruin the doll's uniqueness, which was what drew me to her in the first place.


I am a 15 year old girl, an artist, creator of beauty in words and pictures, a doll collector, as well as an anime lover. I am NOT emo. I am a proud 125 pounds, and though my weight is slightly above the average for a teenage girl, I am perfectly trim and not fat. I eat food every day. I LOVE fried stuff, and I prefer to keep my hamburgers in my gut. And I LOVE the Hi Glamm girls. Not because of fashion, no, but because of the strange, off beat air they carry about them. I know they will never be popular, but that doesn’t matter to me. I will keep my strange, peaky, Italian-designed doll and make her different from any other out there. Good will to you, and I hope you will continue to write interesting articles for people to enjoy in the future. But perhaps you will give the Hi Glamm dolls another look, in a different light this time.

Much love,
~♥Kat