Thursday, September 25, 2008

VH1’s Top 100 of rap music celebrates the positives of the genre

I just noticed something that really caught my attention. VH1 has compiled a list of the top 100 rap music songs. Now that is something that I am sure will create huge debate.

The main question is the importance of groups at the start of rap, the empowerment movement in rap (which was sadly short lived), and the gangsta rap genre that has now become the redundant and endless form that dominates music videos and radio. I for one have no love of gangsta rap, nor the performers that populate the genre.

In it’s birth rap was a celebration of joy. The earliest songs, which I recall from my youth, were not that long ago, just about 29 years now. They were about enjoying friends and good times. The groove was infectious and lead to the growth of the fledgling music format.

But like all things rap grew up. In fact it did so with a speed and determination. By the mid 1980’s until 1992 rap had a meaning. Not all rap, but a good portion of it. There was a pride in the Black community and it was reflected in the music. The music was an oral declaration of unity and progress. This too was reflected in the music videos of the art form, if you were lucky enough to spot one on television.

The first 13 years that rap music existed it was called a fad by mainstream music. It was viewed as a joke. It was diminished and tossed aside by the entire music industry, even though music executives would not dare to stop making the highly lucrative music. But throughout this time rap music was also something that the White masses of the nation neither understood nor craved.

Then there was N.W.A. and the music industry executives found what they had been waiting for. A guttural base expression of African Americans as impoverished, uneducated, violent criminals waiting to be unleashed upon the nation.

I realize, now and then, that N.W.A. was expressing yet another face of what many African Americans experience everyday in America. I understand that they were crying out about the less than American Dream life that was being shoveled into their lives. And there is no doubt in my mind that the intention was never to glorify violence and drugs, or women as sexual gratification objects. But I am equally sure that the music industry sought only that aspect of the sub-genre.

So in looking at the top songs in this sect of music, what should take prominience. The songs that have made the most money, the artists that were promoted most by greedy executives, the songs that hoped to unify and empower African Americans, or those that just celebrated life?

It seems that VH1 considered all these things in making their list.

The number 1 songs was found to be Public Enemy’s Fight The Power.



This song was the pinnacle of the empowerment genre of rap. It was the rally cry for involvement in voting, being active in the community, and making Government accountable to the people. It was just after this song came out that music executive ran to find a distraction, and flooded the airwaves with anything but another rap song of this nature and message.

Second on the list was the Sugar Hill Gang’s Rapper’s Delight



This is the song and group that started the entire music genre. It was the first rap song to burst forth from the nightclubs and basements of the Bronx out to the mainstream of the national airwaves.

Third on the list was the crossover hit by Run DMC Walk This Way.

[The video is blocked from being embedded on a site. Aerosmith has great lawyers it seems.]

So in the first 3 songs we see that the expressions of fun, respect, pride, and ability are the foremost examples of what all rap music really is. And I can agree with these choices.

The top 20 is rounded out by a mix of predominately these themes, with a sprinkle of the more modern, repulsive, generic, pedantic, and demeaning gangsta rap songs that have infected the airwaves since 1992. In fact going through the list you will see that the entire list is filled with mostly artists that ceased being played on the air the day that gangsta rap was born. That’s a statement indeed.

Now I’m sure some will argue this. They will note that Tupac, or Eminem, or Snoop Dogg, and others had meaningful and powerful songs. Some of them are on the list too. But like the law of averages, or probability, even the worst entertainers will eventually get it right once or twice. I mean even William Hung got to make 2 albums and stardom.

The list will be shown on VH1. I’m sure many will have different opinions. But I say that Public Enemy was the greatest rap group ever – both for what they said and what they tried to do. But Heavy D, Sugar Hill Gang, Erik B. and Rahkim, Digital Underground and a few others still make my favorites list too.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

I just saw this VH1 show today and I must say I was very surprised. I grew up listening to rap in the mid 80's and was caught right in the middle of dance rap and gangsta rap. I think both types are important and I enjoyed most of the top 100 songs. The thing about the list that everyone should notice is, rap seems to be getting worse and less original, not better. Just look at the top 20 list, which I thought was pretty good; how many of those songs were made in the year 2000 or later. Also one more note, some rappers, like K.West, I think shouldn't even be on the top 100 list. To me, he is an egotist no talent hack who cries like a baby until he got what he wanted, to be recognized as a "Super" rapper. He to me, is the "Paris Hilton" of rappers.

DJIce said...

J.How. Most of what you said is great, you yourself said "I think both types are important..."

You do not (or do you) personally know K. West? I personally work with a lot of artist (Yes a producer) and one of them even being my own Nephew says I am to arrogant and impossible to work with. I have heard the same with P. Diddy, and etc.

You don't always make it to the top or become successful by being passive. As the young man here said, this busy is run by some Raunchy executives, which will be reflected, since that is what we deal with.

My fault with the "Negative or Gangsta Rap" is how we as adults (at least hopefully) should know most is fiction and some is a acknowledgment of a hard life. At least when we go to the book store it is labeled "Fiction", our children need to know this. They need to know that some of these guys "Rap" these things but yet use that money to take care of their famillies, pay their child support, give to the community etc.

Some of them are just using their music also as therapy, getting it out. The ones that are glorifying their trials and tribulations are the ones that need counselling.

We could turn around and make it all positive by the warning labels, and by talking to our children about it, and by having these artist include or speak about their "Real Lives".

Also, would you rather they do the stuff they rap about for real, or just vent and get it out. Some listen to it for the same reason also.

Also, some are young and a lot are immature - look at the age difference of the good rap vs the Gangsta rap.

So we need some of the now matured Rappers" (which I saw at least one on this show that did actually) start a label that is 100% positive, or start a movement where we are educating our children what they are saying and the meanings and solutions. A new song cant come out that I don't discuss with my children why it is bad, or good, the message and how they could have dealt with it, etc, etc, etc. So lets do our job as Parents and Leaders, lets help our children learn instead of trying to hide. Encourage your children to discuss rap. Let your children see how these rappers really live. Let these children see some positive people that have made it without treating women or others like sh&^%$%. That is what they really listen for. Let them see how it is to find a real good woman or a real good man. Let them see how often those "Stars" stay married. Let them see how the Bling Bling Kings and Queens really end up.

Also, when that child gets hurt by a cop, or mistreated because he's black, or get fired because of some BS, and they then feel like writing a new "Gangsta Rap" song their own dang on selves, leaders, our powerful leaders (the real one's, the one's you find in the community, teaching and training "like myself" ) let them vent, tell them know you see why someone may want to make songs like that, but see, you are going to learn from it, grow above it and come out triumphant!

I said a whole lot more than I ever intended.

Be blessed and Judge not that you may not be judged. Get to know people for yourself, because:

"Everybody that is any enemy, is also somebody's friend." and "Even the worlds best friends, may be somebody's worse enemies."

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the response! I found this website by mistake but after reading your article here and your response, I will make sure to stop by more frequently.

I do agree with just about everything you had to say and I do believe unfortunately some people do take lyrics to some songs to heart. What better example than Eminem -" Stan". But I guess I wasn't looking into all this as serious as you are, I just enjoy the music.

I do understand how it might seem kinda of harsh to me to judge someone I don't know, but for me, I judge people by their character and their actions. K. West said and did things that I total disagree with and some I considered morally wrong. Pushing all that to the side, I have never seen any rapper/singer/actor cry and complain on national TV as much as he has, in his short time of stardom, that he was not recognized in his word, "A super rapstar" Never mind he made comments such as Katrina was a government conspiracy, Bush hates all black people and lets not forget him posing himself as Jesus. He made one song about Jesus, probably cause he liked the hook and it hasn't been done mainstream, and then sold out and made a slew of stereotypical generic songs. I know there are plenty of rappers that have done the same, but for some reason K. West seems to be regarded better than all the other mainstream media rappers.

To be honest, I rarely listen to rap now, because to me its crap and nothing how it use to be. I can only think of a handful of rappers I still follow( ex. Common & Mos Def). The days where rap was good and meant something is gone, and all that left is who can make the most cash the fastest. I loved that VH1 show, but maybe they should make another one called, "The Fall of the Hip Hop Era"

nasim said...

So lets do our job as Parents and Leaders, lets help our children learn instead of trying to hide. Encourage your children to discuss rap.I saw Never mind he made comments such as Katrina was a government conspiracy, Bush hates all black people and lets not forget him posing himself as Jesus.

nasim said...

TV as much as he has, in his short time of stardom, that he was not recognized in his word, "A super rapstar" Never mind he made comments such as Katrina was a government conspiracy, Bush hates all black people and lets not forget him posing himself as Jesus. He made one song about Jesus, probably cause he liked the hook and it hasn't been done mainstream, and then sold out and made a slew of stereotypical generic songs. I know there are plenty of rappers that have done the same, but for some reason K. West seems to be regarded better than all the other mainstream media rappers.